Bhool Chuk Maaf: Rajkummar Rao has become the poster boy for losers; he plays the same character over and over again

Also read – Pokhar Ke Dunu Paar movie review: Poetic and profound, the best Hindi film of the year

Rajkummar Rao in a still from Bhool Chuk Maaf.

Left with no choice, Ranjan agrees. But instead of scouring through LinkedIn and giving an interview or two, he goes to a shady old man played by Sanjay Mishra, who claims to have connections in various government departments. For Rs 6 lakh, the old man promises Ranjan a government job within the two-month deadline that he has been given by his girlfriend’s dad. Ranjan arranges for the money by selling his mother’s jewellery against her knowledge. When his girlfriend — she’s played by Wamiqa Gabbi, by the way — offers to lend him some of her dowry, he pretends to be outraged, but agrees three seconds later. This is the guy we’re supposed to be rooting for. He doesn’t have a single redeeming quality. But for some reason, it’s characters like Ranjan that Rao gravitates towards these days. There’s nothing wrong with playing terrible people on screen, but it can become monotonous for the audience when an actor — especially someone of Rao’s talent — reduces themselves to a type. If Ranjan were to walk into one of his other movies, you wouldn’t even notice.

Barring a couple of films in which he played cops — Badhaai Do and Bheed — Rao’s been stuck doing the same small town schtick. In Stree, he plays a loafer who falls in love with a ghost lady. In Chhalaang, he’s barely able to secure work as a school PT teacher. In Shimla Mirchi, he stalks a woman in the hills because he has nothing else to do. In Roohi, he plays a kidnapper. Before you say anything, this isn’t a real job. In Guns & Gulaabs, he runs some kind of cycle repair shop; in Vicky Vidya Ka Woh Wala Video, he’s a mehendi artist who’s managed to get married to someone way out of his league; in Mr & Mrs Mahi, he’s forced to sit behind the counter of his dad’s sports store.

In each of these projects, Rao’s characters are barely-functional man-children. The only reason they find employment is because their love life relies on it. Mr & Mrs Mahi is probably the worst offender; not only is Rao’s character in it severely immature, he’s also rather rude to his angelic wife. He grooms her to give up on her dreams of becoming a doctor, all because he wants to live his fantasies vicariously through her. In a more sensible movie, she’d have knocked him over the head with his own hockey stick and walked out. Instead, Rao’s character is projected as some sort of valorous hero; a champion of women who empowers his wife to become a cricketer.

Bhool Chuk Maaf isn’t as well-made as either Bheed or Badhaai Do, two movies that understood that people live inside prisons of society’s making. Ranjan’s frustration manifests in horrible behaviour that the movie never fully addresses. Sure, he has a change of heart at the end, when he realises that he shouldn’t have stolen a job with someone else’s name on it. But what about his other faults? How about we address the entitlement that folks like him and Ajju bhaiyya from Bawaal walk around with? It was funny the first time, when he played a person like this in Bareilly Ki Barfi all those years ago, but that’s because his character in that film was genuinely endearing.

Read more – Loveyapa: Junaid Khan plays the world’s biggest red flag again, this time in Advait Chandan’s outdated romantic comedy

Wamiqa Gabbi in a still from Bhool Chuk Maaf.

The unimaginative writing aside, Rao’s work in these movies itself is an issue. There’s a tendency to lean into the dialect, which often sounds interchangeable. There’s also a tendency to have outbursts; there’s a false sense of pride in these people, bordering on arrogance. Rao has a difficult time injecting them with vulnerabilities. These movies, including Bhool Chuk Maaf, leave no room for introspection and indecision. The men at their centre are empowered by the filmmakers to strut through life with a delusional overconfidence. Some movies, like Monica O My Darling, are smart enough to call their so-called hero out on their bashfulness. Others, like Srikanth, are too terrible to take seriously.

But there is a difference between creating complex characters and two-dimensional oafs. In Bhool Chuk Maaf, when Ranjan is terrible, he’s uniformly terrible. And when his redemption arc is complete, it’s as if his entire personality has changed. Neither version is particularly realistic, because most humans exist somewhere in the middle of this spectrum. Rao has played such characters many times in the past, in movies such as Shahid and Aligarh, in Trapped and Newton. It’s about time he returns to his roots, not for our sake, but his own.